Dear Planning Commissioners,

The proposed 5.23 acre portion of the Corona Station Residential Project ignores the fact that it is an integral portion of the adjacent SMART train station. This proposal is more suburban (infill) sprawl. It is more of the same.

What about this residential development is Transit Oriented Development? Nothing.

These houses are more suburban sprawl with two car parking garages each. These proposed houses will be sold to people who may or may not ever use the train.

Point #1: Why don’t we encourage several 4 to 5 story buildings with a much higher density than that proposed? For comparison, what about several buildings like the new Marina Crossing apartments with 92 units each?

Point #2: There is no “there” there. As a rule, east side Petaluma suffers from a lack of land use and architecture that grants a sense of place. Much of the east side is drive by suburban housing tracts.

This proposal does nothing to celebrate the new train station.

This proposal does nothing to anchor the major, important intersection of North McDowell and Corona Road. How will you even know that there is a new train station there? All you will see is a parking lot full of cars on the corner.

I believe that this site provides a huge opportunity to do the following two things:

Solution A: Let’s create much more density (many more housing units) to provide some real Transit Oriented Development at this site. Make these units smaller and somewhat more “affordable”.

Solution B: Make this project Stand Out as different from the monotony of residential suburban sprawl. Provide an anchor for the intersection of North McDowell and Corona Road. Let’s encourage the developer to create a sense of place at this intersection. Provide an anchor with taller, bigger, more dense buildings.

This location deserves much better than more of the same. Usually, the developer drives the overall vision and plan for the site. But the conditional use permit puts the Planning Commission in the driver’s seat.

Ten years from now, when the new SMART corridor is fully functional, what are we going to wish was at this residential site?

Yes, we need the park and ride parking lot. But we also need some for real Transit Oriented Development housing next to it.

New Transit Oriented Development project proposed for Corona Road and North McDowell

This notification sign has gone up at Corona Road and North McDowell Street. Across the railroad tracks from the new Brody Ranch Development and also the location for the East Petaluma SMART Station. Another 110 housing units in a mix of single family buildings and duplex townhomes all smushed close together. These units have two car garages each, 2 to 4 bedroom "entry level homes" previously thought to sell for around $600,000. As I wrote in March, "In the end, we are going to wind up with more housing sprawl that results in more car traffic on the roads or else we are going to create an East Petaluma Train station destination that is pedestrian friendly and (hopefully) provides less expensive housing. We are going to provide more housing in east Petaluma where people no longer need their cars and actually use the train or else we are going to have a suburban park and ride train station where people mostly drive to the Corona Road station. Which will it be? This is a huge opportunity for us in Petaluma to create a “sense of place” on the east side and to get people out of their cars and onto the train." This project proposal is, in my opinion, more of the same on the East Side. But it is consistent with the new Brody Ranch and it is also consistent with the Transit Oriented Development Master Plan approved by the City in 2013. Is that good enough for this site? This project is also complicated by the ongoing negotiations with the City to get the developer to build the parking lot for the Corona Road SMART Station on this same empty lot. Planning Commission hearing November 12th!